Is It Wrong to Question God? What Scripture Says About Doubt

Most Christians—if they're honest—have moments when they wonder: Why, God? Whether it's suffering, silence, or spiritual dryness, questioning can feel like doubt creeping in where faith should be. But Scripture and tradition tell a different story. They show us that questioning is not the opposite of faith—it can be an expression of it.

When we question God, we're engaging with Him. We're reaching for clarity, truth, and connection. The Bible is filled with people who brought their confusion, fear, and frustration directly to God—and were not rejected for doing so. Instead, they were often drawn deeper into relationship with Him.

This article explores what Scripture and the Catholic tradition teach about questioning God—and how doubt, when approached with humility, can become a doorway to greater trust.

Biblical Instances of Questioning God

Job’s Lament

Job, a righteous man who faced immense suffering, openly questioned God’s justice and reasons for his afflictions. In Job 10:3, he asks, “Is it good for You that You should oppress, that You should despise the work of Your hands and smile on the counsel of the wicked?” Despite his profound anguish and questioning, Job’s story concludes with a deeper understanding of God’s sovereignty and his own limitations (Job 42:1-6).

What we learn from Job is that God can handle our honesty. He doesn't silence Job—He responds. And He responds not with rebuke, but with revelation. Job’s questions are not signs of faithlessness, but expressions of trust that God is worth questioning.

Habakkuk’s Inquiry

The prophet Habakkuk challenged God’s plan to use the Babylonians to punish Judah, struggling to reconcile this with God’s nature. In Habakkuk 1:13, he expresses, “Your eyes are too pure to look on evil; you cannot tolerate wrongdoing. Why then do you tolerate the treacherous?” This dialogue illustrates that seeking clarity from God is a part of faith (Habakkuk 2:1-4).

What stands out in Habakkuk is his decision to wait for God’s answer: “I will stand at my guard post… and watch to see what He will say to me.” This posture of questioning with expectation is a model for us. Questions are not wrong when they are grounded in relationship.

Thomas the Apostle’s Doubt

After the resurrection, Thomas refused to believe until he saw Christ’s wounds himself. In John 20:25, he says, “Unless I see the nail marks in His hands and put my finger where the nails were, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe.” Instead of condemning Thomas, Jesus invites him to touch His wounds, affirming that faith can grow through honest questioning (John 20:27-29).

Thomas wasn’t lacking faith—he was longing for proof that love had truly conquered death. And Jesus met him right there. If God Himself did not shame a doubting disciple, we can be confident that our questions do not disqualify us from relationship.

Jesus and the Ministry of Questions

Jesus was not afraid of questions. In fact, He asked many of His own:

• “Who do you say that I am?” (Matthew 16:15)

• “Why are you afraid?” (Mark 4:40)

• “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (Matthew 27:46)

These are not rhetorical devices—they are invitations. Jesus used questions to draw people into reflection, transformation, and intimacy. He honored the struggle. He dignified the process. Even His final breath included a question, echoing Psalm 22, reminding us that even in agony, it's okay to cry out for answers.

If Jesus Himself asked hard questions, we should never fear doing the same.

Catholic Teachings on Doubt

The Catholic Church acknowledges that doubt can be a natural part of faith development. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 2088-2089) distinguishes between:

• Involuntary Doubt – Hesitation in believing or difficulty in overcoming objections related to the faith. This can lead to spiritual growth when explored with sincerity.

• Voluntary Doubt – Willfully disregarding or rejecting what God has revealed and what the Church teaches. This can lead one away from faith.

Rather than rejecting those who doubt, the Church encourages engagement with Scripture, prayer, and theological study to seek clarity (CCC 158).

Saint Anselm described theology as fides quaerens intellectum—faith seeking understanding. Doubt, when rooted in humility, is often the beginning of deeper formation.

Even saints like Augustine, Teresa of Ávila, and Thérèse of Lisieux wrestled with spiritual darkness and questions they could not resolve immediately. But they brought them to God.

Embracing Questions as a Path to Deeper Faith

Questioning, when approached with humility and a genuine desire for understanding, can lead to a more profound and resilient faith. Scripture encourages believers to seek wisdom and understanding:

• James 1:5 – “If any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask of God, who gives to all liberally and without reproach, and it will be given to him.”

• Mark 9:24 – The father of a possessed boy cries out, “I believe; help my unbelief!” showing that doubt and faith can coexist.

• Matthew 7:7 – “Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.”

When we question God in prayer, in Scripture, or in conversation with fellow believers, we are not weakening our faith—we are strengthening it.

What Should I Do With My Doubts?

• Pray honestly. Don’t filter your fears in prayer. God can handle raw truth.

• Bring questions into Scripture. Practice Lectio Divina with difficult passages. Let the Word speak.

• Talk to someone wise. A priest, spiritual director, or trusted mentor can help you see more clearly.

• Read Catholic thinkers. Church Fathers, theologians, and modern spiritual writers can walk with you.

• Stay in community. Doubt grows in isolation. Share your questions where love and truth coexist.

Conclusion

Questioning God is not inherently wrong; it reflects a dynamic and seeking faith. Scriptural examples and Catholic teachings suggest that doubt, when navigated thoughtfully, can lead to spiritual growth and a deeper understanding of one's beliefs.

Faith isn’t always a straight line. Sometimes it bends through shadows and silence, and sometimes it doubles back through doubt. But as long as the questions are held in the presence of God, they are holy.

We’ve gone through a lot of Bible in this article, which is always the time I like to bring up the Catholic Study Bible by Ignatius Press. Decades of Catholic scholarship have gone into producing this study Bible that stands head and shoulders above not only other Catholic Bibles, but the very best of the Protestant Bibles, as well. I would give one to every Catholic in the English-speaking world, if I could.

---

Want more articles like this? Support the ministry at ko-fi.com/convertingtohope. Your generosity helps keep this work going.